Why bonuses don't motivate employees

Published on

In our sessions, we talk about how important it is to get to know each individual and to understand what motivates them, in order to get the best out of them (and minimise the risk of employment problems). Some will be more motivated by money, and others less so, and of course, this will vary according to the sector. However, they will probably not be as motivated by money as many companies think they are.

In this clip, Dan Ariely (James B. Duke Professor of Psychology and Behavioral Economics at Duke University and author of "Payoff: The Hidden Logic That Shapes Our Motivations) discusses how compliments and recognition more effective than bonuses motivating employees to work harder, like many companies believe. https://youtu.be/rbI8FDRsqfw

This is an idea that was also proven in Frederick Herzberg's research into motivational theory. His research showed that salary/bonus is one of the "hygiene" needs (or maintenance factors) in the workplace. People will strive to achieve "hygiene" needs because they they are unhappy without them, but once satisfied the effect soon wears off - satisfaction is temporary. Organisations often fail to understand that people are not "motivated" by addressing "hygiene" needs. People are only truly motivated by enabling them to reach for and satisfy the factors that Herzberg identified as real motivators, such as achievement, advancement, development, etc., which represent a far deeper level of meaning and fulfilment.

So, leaders and managers - pick up the phone or even better, drop by someone's desk, and give them a compliment or recognition. It's easy and the research shows, it works!

Related Articles

Guest Q&A - Steven McCann on alcohol culture in professional services

Steven McCann, Founder of MCG Consulting, joins us to talk about alcohol addiction, alcohol culture in professional services, and why recovery-informed workplaces matter.

Four reasons workplaces should be thinking about the topic of suicide

Suicide remains a workplace taboo despite affecting millions; open conversations, training, and employer support can save lives and strengthen wellbeing.

AI in HR Tech: a cautionary tale

A cautionary tale about the risks of AI in HR tech and the importance of thoughtful integration.

Happy hour? A conversation about alcohol and work – culture, risk and belonging

From post-deal drinks to client events and team celebrations, alcohol is woven into workplace culture. Yet when something goes wrong, it’s rarely seen as ‘just a drink’.

With new duties on employers to prevent sexual harassment, and growing attention on workplace risk and inclusion, it’s time to take a more intentional look at how alcohol shapes workplace culture – and the risks it carries.

This short, focused webinar will explore:

• How alcohol contributes to conduct, harassment and reputational risk

• The assumptions we make about what’s normal, social or expected

• How alcohol intersects with inclusion, wellbeing and boundaries

• What to think about when conducting risk assessments and looking at policies

• Practical steps to build positive connection while protecting what matters

Speakers:

Helen Dallimore
Head of Training, Byrne Dean

An experienced facilitator, trainer and former employment lawyer, Helen works with organisations to strengthen leadership capability and embed respectful workplace behaviours. She brings particular expertise in creating inclusive cultures where people feel safe, respected and able to thrive.

Cicilia Wan
Principal Consultant, Byrne Dean

A former employment lawyer and experienced Headof Employee Relations in global financial services, Cicilia has seen first-hand how alcohol canaffect conduct at work. She brings deep expertise in leadership, culture and managing people risk.

Steven McCann
Founder and Director, MCG Consulting

A leading voice in workplace addiction and recovery inclusion, Steven advises organisations on addiction awareness, recovery-informed culture and social mobility. He has spoken at the Bank of England and works regularly with law societies, the Legal Services Board and institutions across law, finance and corporate sectors.

Training Zone: Five 2025 training trends to address the knowing-doing gap

Matt Dean explores the knowledge gaps organisations are looking to close in 2025.

HR Magazine: Lab employee wins €10k after HR recorded him

Amanda Okill shares guidance on the role of HR in building trust and fostering a speak up culture.